By Rickey Singh
– in Bridgetown
IN Caribbean party politics it’s not surprising for disagreements between a Prime Minister and cabinet colleague to occasionally hit media headlines. But it’s quite a rarity, if not unique, for the head of government to be publicly severed an ultimatum by one of his ministerial colleagues.
But that’s the scenario which has surfaced in Barbados where Prime Minister Freundel Stuart, learnt from a private memorandum, now made public, that he either take action to correct a problem identified by the Minister of Agriculture, Dr David Estwick, or he (Estwick) would quit the cabinet.
Dr Estwick, a former Minister of Finance and Economic Affairs, continues to display a surprising level of political innocence in relation to the workings of politics and government in a Westminster-style democracy.
“…it’s quite a rarity, if not unique, for the head of government to be publicly severed an ultimatum by one of his ministerial colleagues. But that’s the scenario which has surfaced in Barbados where Prime Minister Freundel Stuart, learnt from a private memorandum, now made public, that he either take action to correct a problem identified by the Minister of Agriculture, Dr David Estwick, or he (Estwick) would quit the cabinet.”
Consequently, his repeated missteps in public confrontations with Prime Minister Stuart must be quite unsettling for even his faithful St. Philips-West constituents, not to mention the amusement he unwittingly provides for political detractors and opponents.

Some eleven months ago, against the backdrop of the 2013 Christmas holidays, Dr Estwick had begun to send more than mixed signals about his disagreements with the government’s fiscal and economic policies and, more surprisingly, Prime Minister Stuart’s leadership style.
‘ALTERNATIVE’ PACKAGE
However, to make a long spicy political story short, Dr Estwick got his requested day in court, so to speak, with Prime Minister Stuart conceding to his demand to present at a cabinet meeting an alternative package of fiscal measures to that of Finance Minister Chris Sinckler’s that could also help address the problem of impending retrenchment of public sector workers confronting the government
Whatever transpired in the process between Finance Minister Sinckler’s controversial approaches and Estwick’s “alternative proposals”, staggered retrenchment of public sector workers has been the norm during 2014.
And while all who live in Barbados continue to face the harsh realities of rising food prices and general cost of living, Dr Estwick has now come forth, with customary passion, to hit the headlines with his new confrontational challenge to Prime Minister Stuart.
‘FED UP’ ESTWICK
This time – on the eve of the Prime Minister’s official visit this past weekend to Cuba to participate in the fifth CARICOM/Cuba Summit in Havana, Estwick chose to disclose – as reported in last ‘Sunday Sun’ (Barbados newspaper) – how “fed up” he is over the non-implementation of instructions given by him (with Mr Stuart’s knowledge), on the Barbados Cane Industry Restructuring Project.
Estwick’s anger was shown in a seven-page letter sent to the Prime Minister with a warning that “this is the last time I will raise this matter with you….”.
That letter, which in effect constituted Estwick’s clearest public ultimatum to Stuart, could well turn out to be his last crossing of the proverbial sword with the leader of the governing Democratic Labour Party and second-term Prime Minister.
After all, if Estwick is fully conscious of the depth of the fiscal/economic challenges confronting the government ahead of Christmas and next year’s coming national budget, as well as feeling there has really been no improvements in personal, or official ‘working’ relations between him and the Prime Minister, then this may be the appropriate time to part company with a Stuart-led DLP administration.
It must be quite embarrassing for the Prime Minister’s leadership to be publicly chastised –for the second time – by Estwick. Yet, Stuart could either choose to ignore his controversial cabinet colleague’s challenge and, instead, leave him to make the next move, consistent with his ultimatum.
On the other hand, rather than face cabinet dismissal Dr Estwick could quit his portfolio and remain, if so disposed, as a DLP parliamentarian. This could be uncomfortable for the Prime Minister but the voting status quo in the House would remain a majority of two for the governing DLP in the 30-member Parliament.
Some observers feel that if Estwick honestly feels he has had enough of disagreements with Stuart’s leadership, both at the level of party and government, he could well quit as cabinet minister and, like former Prime Minister and leader of the Barbados Labour Party, Owen Arthur, sit as an independent in the House and leave the DLP to govern with a one-vote majority until new general elections. But that’s almost three years away.
(Rickey Singh is a noted Guyana-born Caribbean journalist based in Barbados)







