Daughter screams and collapses as jury frees incest accused

A DREADLOCKED Cecil Smith was on Wednesday freed of the charges of incest and indecent assault allegedly committed on his daughter in 2009, when she was 15 years old.

And almost simultaneously with announcement of the jury’s verdict, the now 20-year-old daughter, who was sitting in the courtroom as a spectator, began screaming before she collapsed.

Policemen and women had to lift her out of the courtroom to the Police Outpost, where the screaming continued as she kept crying and shouting, “No one knows the trouble I went through, and this man has been freed!”

Whilst the young woman wept and shouted, her dreadlocked father stealthily exited the dock and strode to freedom.

The girl had related how her father had sexually violated her and had even threatened her at knife-point, causing her to give in to his demand for sex.

But her story was not foolproof, as it was full of inconsistencies.
She had told the magistrate one story when the matter was fresh in her mind, and then had told the judge and jury another story in the High Court.

When asked to clarify this inconsistency, she had told both Defence Counsel Keavon Bess and Prosecutrix Mrs. Tashana Lake that both her accounts were in fact true representations of what had transpired.

Justice James Bovell-Drakes, presiding in the trial, had summed up the case with the inconsistencies; and after deliberating for about two hours, the jury returned with a unanimous verdict of not guilty.

The girl had told the judge and jury that the acts had been committed on her in August 2009, when she was 15. According to her, after she had told her father that she did not have a boyfriend, he had told her that if she had sex with him, she would be able to have a boyfriend, and would get permission to go places.

The virtual complainant had also testified in court that she had been made to strip naked for the sex ordeal, and had also been ordered to “wine and kiss daddy.”

But under cross-examination by defence counsel Mr. Keavon Bess, the girl admitted that although she had told the judge and jury that her father had had sex with her on the morning and the night of August 17, 2009, she had told the magistrate, when the matter was fresh in her mind, that he did not have sex with her in the morning; it was only in the night.

Asked for an explanation, the girl had maintained that she did not lie to either the magistrate or to the judge and jury.

Even when prosecutor Mr. Tashana Lake had intervened to get a plausible explanation from her, the girl had maintained her story.

Accordingly, defence counsel Mr Bess had made a no-case submission at the end of the prosecution’s case, but that had been overruled.

The accused began his defence by telling the court, in an unsworn statement from the dock, that he was innocent of the charges. He said that his daughter was a bad-behaved girl who had caused her mother to send her back to Guyana from Trinidad.

After the girl had returned from Trinidad, she had gone to spend time with a cousin who, because of her behavior, had to send her back to her father.

The accused said that he had gone to the bedroom where his daughter was, and had flogged her because of the reports he had received.
Later, he learnt that it had been reported that he had had sex with his daughter. That, he said, was untrue, and he was asking the jury to find him not guilty.

The defence counsel had urged the jury to give his client the benefit of the doubt by returning a verdict of not guilty; but the prosecutrix had asked the jury to return a verdict in accordance with the evidence and the oath they had taken.
Written By George Barclay

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.