Mr. Raphael playing political hardball with the ECB

POLITICS exists in every organisation, including cricket, at the highest level. The decision by the government to form the IMC following the Honourable Chief Justice’s ruling will be judged by the public; after all, the Essequibo Cricket Board and Mr. Claude Raphael have joined the IMC’s bus. What is happening in Guyana presently is a caricature of the GCB and unfortunately it has transcended onto the county boards. Please permit me to respond to Mr. Claude Raphael’s letter appearing in the Kaieteur News dated 2012/08/03 and captioned: ‘ Mr. Stephney has missed the bus by quite a long way.’
I will indeed be disappointed if I should have missed the bus Mr. Raphael, but I wish to caution you to have on your seat belt since you would normally sit at the front as you have been doing at the GCB’s head table for the last 30 years. It bothers me that the former Chairman of selectors and WICB director knows the modus operandi of the ECB better than he knows his own home, the Demerara Cricket Board(DCB). What is even alarming is that he has never criticised the DCB during the bitter dispute involving the two factions that have now led to the non-existence of the once dominant board. Perhaps it has suited his agenda to remain silent; yet on the contrary he is loud in condemnation of the ECB. It is not my intention to defend the ECB since there are more prominent officials that are capable of doing so. Instead, I will continue to expose the inequality and total disrespect that the ECB has endured for over 30 years; much of which is attributable to inept selection policies!
The arbitrary decision by the ECB to participate in the last elections of the GCB seems to be the main dilemma of Mr. Raphael in his continued tirade against some members of the ECB, including his former GCB colleague Asif Ahmad and the current secretary Mr. Auto Christiani.
These servants of cricket are decent and industrious leaders who have served the game well despite the herculean task of managing eight geographical areas that are vast and wide and with very little resources (beg for authorised miniscule subvention from the GCB). The voluminous questions posed by Mr. Raphael involving the current state of affairs (under 15, 17, 19 and women’s cricket) which he rhetorically asks cannot be ignored, but the answers are anyone’s guess. The WICB has made it clear that they will not recognise any entity other than the GCB for the selection of teams to represent Guyana.  It is common sense, if not politically prudent, that both the ECB and the BCB have participated in organised matches for the purpose of giving the players an opportunity to be selected, since unfortunately the IMC could not have functioned in this regard as was intended. The Georgetown Cricket Association and the East Coast Cricket Board displayed tacit objection but benefited from the fact that players from their constituents were also selected. It is no secret who are organising and selecting these national teams, but there is no other alternative until the current impasse is resolved with the implementation of a new GCB constitution and the holding of new elections. In the meantime, Mr. Raphael’s deliberate attempt to vilify the ECB for the current crisis is only a sordid distraction from consolidating the immense work of the IMC which at this time should have drafted and refined the new constitution of the GCB and which will need parliamentary support to become operational. Incidentally, Mr. Raphael is one of the main technocrats of the piece of legislation. I hope that he will be doing the same for the DCB; a board that is in peril and which needs serious answers for the transformation of the administration of cricket in Guyana.
I wish to link a few global political injustices to that of our cricket, which should identify the inflexible muscles of the strong men at the helm of these organisations:

1- The current war in Syria that continues to claim innocent lives with culpability being laid on President Bashar al-Assad and his regime. Yet powerhouses Russia and China refuse to sanction  decisive action against the country, even with overwhelming evidence of genocide.
2- President Barrack Obama’s refusal to even mention the removal of the economic embargo against Cuba which remains a terrible and inhumane injustice. Doing so may risk his re-election chances.
3- President Robert Mugabe’s defiance of the electoral will of the people of Zimbabwe which he continues to illegally govern with an iron fist.
4- The cash for votes debacle that nearly brought FIFA to its knees, yet the main conspirator remains a key government minister. Another official may even return to helm of football when his suspension is over for the same incident.
5- Former President Nelson Mandela’s prolonged and unwarranted imprisonment for fighting against apartheid.

Let’s juxtapose this with our local cricket and examine the actions of these strongmen who are just as unconscionable:

1- The shocking omission of Essequibian Clain Williams from the national under-19 squad in 1998 despite being one of the leading run scorers in the trials. He was initially selected as was sanctioned by the selectors, only for his selection to be overturned by a powerful executive member. This fact can be verified by Mr. Alfred Maycock, who was one of the junior selectors at the time.

2- Prior to now, the GCB was annually sending a representative team to Canada as part of Guyana’s independence celebrations. Unfortunately, not even one Essequibian was considered to be worthy of selection even for the purpose of gaining exposure. I will always have to refer to Dinesh Joseph as one of the finest opening batsmen never to play for Guyana despite his masterful inter-county century against test bowlers Reon King and Colin Stuart. In fact, Joseph did attend senior trials under the tenure of Mr. Raphael. However it seems that the selection of the team then was a foregone conclusion even in the wake of Mr. Raphael’s continued pronouncement that Joseph never attended trials due to his own neglect.

3- The ECB is the only county board in the history of cricket in Guyana whose players have to endure the wrath of the administratively disingenuous. The players are being told to travel and play cricket in Berbice on the same day while the other two counties will complain whenever they are dissatisfied with certain conditions and their concerns are met with swift action. An Essequibian umpire was banished from officiating at the inter-county level again because he had called off a game that Berbice thought  they should have won under dangerous and fading light. Just who is controlling the game in the middle? The BCB complained and the rest is history.

4- The unprofessional and embarrassing treatment of national captain and WI batsman Ramnaresh Sarwan must not go unnoticed, since his continuing omission from the West Indies team is a reflection of the executive will of the administration to unjustifiably punish the player.

5- The ECB in collaboration with a corporate sponsor had organised a T20 tournament which was sanctioned by the GCB before it was injuncted. Several national players were invited, including Christopher Barnwell, Jonathan Foo, Rajendra Chandrika among others and who had given their commitment to participate. Interestingly and deliberately, the national players could not have played because of being threatened following the ECB’s decision then to support the IMC. Our national fast bowler Ransford Beaton had to be a spectator from the stands. However, two weeks after the BCB was doing the same and the national players were playing without interference. The decision by Alvin Johnson, Veren Chintamani and Fizul Bacchus to remain loyal to the GCB (Phantom Group) is their personal choices and not the official stance of the ECB.

6- The omission of Trevor Benn from the national team without playing a match was very devastating to the individual and while the excuse given was that it was for cricketing reasons, I wonder whether Benn was there as a footballer! Why not omit someone who had failed instead of Benn who was never given a chance (Benn was removed from the squad and not the eleven).

These are some of the plights of the ECB and Guyana’s cricket which I will continue to speak out against and remain a poisonous spear that will devastate cricket in Guyana if the casual and repetitive attitude continues. I am optimistic however that  the sudden vigilance of Mr. Raphael that the public will also ensure that the governance of the game will be transparent; open for equal opportunities for the players regardless of their county and that the imminent administrative transition will be a success for Guyana and the West Indies.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.