Kaieteur News editorial riddled with inaccuracies

THE Kaieteur News editorial of Saturday June 2, 2012 was riddled with inaccuracies, misinformation and can be dubbed as “roadside gyaff” among friends who were most likely intoxicated. It would appear that the editor and publisher of Kaieteur News have joined the band of individuals in this country who have personal vendettas against individuals and institutions.  I am not surprised but I’m certainly confused by the appalling departure from basic journalistic ethics. This apology of an editorial is obviously an attempt to serve the interests of their political masters.
The first paragraph states, “Ever since the life of the Ethnic Relations Commission (ERC) came to an end and President Bharrat Jagdeo decided to extend the operation, there has been objection by the political opposition, especially the People’s National Congress Reform. In keeping with the statutes, the political parties, the non-governmental organisations, the religious organisations and social groups were all asked to name representatives to the ERC…”,  sets the tone for creating mischief and deception.
This is a complete distortion about the facts and is mere fabrication to confuse and mislead the public.
The revised 2003 Constitution provides for the establishment of the parliamentary Committee of Appointments (COA). This body is mandated by the constitution, the Standing Orders as well as resolutions of the 8th Parliament with regard to an agreed consensual mechanism for the appointment of the Judicial, Public and Police Service Commissions and the rights commissions, including the Ethnic Relations Commission.
Firstly, the COA must agree on the list of entities (from civil society) it wishes to invite to make nominations with regard to any of the rights commissions in accordance with the specific articles of the constitution. This list must be submitted to a vote of 2/3 majority. Having achieved this vote, the COA then proceeds to invite the agreed entities to submit their nominations and after this is completed, the COA submits the actual names to a majority vote of the National Assembly.
The COA of the 9th Parliament comprised members of the PPP/C, PNCR-IG and the AFC.
This COA unanimously agreed to submit the list of entities for the nominations to the ERC on May 10, 2007; on the floor of the House the PNCR-IG objected to a clause in the schedule of the motion, this was accepted by the government and it was put to the vote. The AFC voted in favour with the PPP/C to the amended
Version, but the PNCR-IG did not support it, thus the motion to consult 162 entities for nominations to the ERC did not succeed in obtaining the 2/3 majority, falling short by two votes.
The matter therefore reverted to the COA. By August 2007, having been unable in the committee to resolve the problem of the inclusion of the IRO, the government approached the National Assembly by way of a motion declaring the Committee’s inability to reach “consensus on the way forward …and the  issues preventing the reconstitution of the ERC may remain unresolved for an extended period of time” and called on the National Assembly to advise the President to take “such steps so as to enable the ERC to continue to carry out its constitutional responsibilities in the interim”( see Resolution No. 36, August 9, 2007).
This was passed with a majority vote. The COA subsequently tried repeatedly on many occasions during 2008-2011to resolve the differences but did not succeed. The lack of the appointment of the ERC falls on the shoulders of the COA and the National Assembly. The President had nothing to do with this and in fact was given a mandate from the National Assembly to allow the ERC to continue to function.
Therefore, all of paragraph one is incorrect and misleading.
Furthermore, no political party (was) is required or invited to name representatives to the ERC. A quick check by the author of the editorial of Article 212 A and B of the Constitution would have discovered that the ERC comprises  a representative of labour, women, youth, business and the Christian, Hindu and Muslim faiths. All of which had been subjected to a selection process agreed between the government and the PNC opposition in the period 2001-2003.
It is unfortunate that Kaieteur News would target the former Chairman of the ERC, Bishop Juan Edghill as chief among “political animals incapable of dealing fairly and squarely with the issues of discrimination” when it is public knowledge that the representative of women’s  organisations, who at the time of sitting as a commissioner was also the Head of the National Congress of Women – the women’s arm of the PNC/R and subsequently a member of parliament for the PNC/R-IG, the other was as the representative of youths, the head of the Progressive Youth Organisation. The latter in June 2006, stopped attending meetings as he was being nominated to the list of candidates for the General and Regional Elections in 2006. He was subsequently appointed a minister. The former continued to function until January 2009, even though her name was on her party’s list.
The annual and special reports of the ERC handed to the Speaker of the National Assembly in keeping with the constitutional provisions are “proof of the pudding”; a perusal of these will indicate if the ERC as the first rights commission to be appointed and oldest did or did not carry out its mandate “fairly and squarely”. The vilification of my role as chairman cannot detract from the facts that have been chronicled and publicly laid in the National Assembly and on the ERC’s website.
A meeting of National Stakeholders Forum (NSF) in 2008 under the chairmanship of President Jagdeo and attended by 100 stakeholders representing labour, business, religious bodies, women, Amerinidan organisations and the PPP/C, the PNCR-IG, AFC and GAP urged that the COA continue to make efforts to resolve issues and appoint the ERC whilst agreeing to extensions of the life of the terms of the existing commissioners until there was agreement at the parliamentary level. It should be noted that some of these civil society bodies had elected these commissioners in 2002-2003. Kaieteur News needs to check its archives as after each of these a joint press release was crafted and released to the media and the public. At this particular meeting, this release was drafted by Mr. Lance Carberry and Ms. Gail Teixeira and accepted by all unanimously.
To further strengthen the resolve to reconstitute the ERC whilst allowing it to keep the ERC functioning, a motion was laid by the government recapping the NSF decisions and urging movement on a series of issues regarding the appointment of all the rights commissions by a specific date. This too was adopted by the National Assembly.
The editorial became more interesting in Paragraph four, when it falsely stated that Juan Edghill was nominated by the Inter-Religious Organisation (IRO) and that the IRO no longer wanted him as their nominee. This statement could be described at best as malicious, wicked and emanating from a depraved mind. The IRO was not even in existence when the ERC was constituted in the 2002/2003 period.  Therefore the IRO could not have been asked to name a nominee for the ERC.  So it could never have said it no longer wanted Juan Edghill. In fact, l was nominated by the Christian bodies as its representative and then elected by the Commission as its chairperson at the first meeting in September 2003. President Jagdeo appointed all the commissioners and we were sworn in as required, but the Commissioners emerged out of a process from the civil society bodies.
Rather, conversely, it was the PNCR-IG’s obsession to not have the IRO in the 2007-2011 period be included as one of 162 entities as it feared that the IRO may nominate Bishop Edghill.
Paragraph Six could be best described as lies, more lies and damn lies. The private sector neither the Labour Movement withdrew their nominees from the ERC. The constitution is clear on how members from a constitutional commission can be removed from office. The facts are that Mr. Norman McLean, very early in the life of the commission resigned due to his workload and to pursue other interests and Mr. Andrew Garnett, who represented labour resigned when he was not re-elected as president of the TUC. It had nothing to do with the current issue under consideration. However, the alternate members of both bodies to the ERC, Mr. John Willems and Mr. Carvil Duncan, became commissioners. Therefore, the assertion of the author that the Commission was defunct is not true.
For the sake of public consumption, I call upon the Editor and publisher of Kaieteur News to stop the “roadside gyaff” and to produce the evidence.
What is the sin in participating in an Appreciation Day activity for an outgoing President? I refuse to be judged and measured by the hate-driven conclusions of the Kaieteur News. The President’s Appreciation Day was one of the largest turnouts of Guyanese of all walks of life, a vindication of his contribution to Guyana and its development under his leadership.
Paragraph Nine states that I was on a political platform while serving as chairman of the ERC. This is what can be called a barefaced attempt to deceive, since Kaieteur News widely publicised the fact that from June  2011 onwards, I was debarred by an injunction filed by the then Leader of the Opposition, Mr. Robert Corbin, from carrying out my constitutional function as chairman of the ERC. I subsequently resigned prior to my acceptance of the position I now occupy. I publicly declared my support for the PPP/C and campaigned for the PPP/C as a citizen with the same rights as any other citizen. I have to thank Mr. Corbin who through his actions freed me to make such choices,
Why hasn’t KN written or questioned the impartiality of a sitting commissioner in 2006 whose name appeared on an opposition slate and continued to sit on the commission as a candidate during the 2006 elections?  Nor has the KN found other similar situations in other rights commissions during the 2011 elections. Watch the Double Standard Mr. Editor.
I offer my strongest rebuke at this attempt of mischief and seeking to distort the truth. It is not too late for an apology and necessary corrections to be made.
This strongly worded response is regretted, but is necessitated by the gravity of the unfounded statements and bald-faced attack on the ERC in this editorial to merely give succor to a political parties’ assertion of “collateral damage”.
If the KN continues like this, it will lose its readership who will not trust what it writes and then it too might suffer from “collateral damage”!!!
Please be reminded “meekness is not weakness” but it’s rather strength under control.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.