Very interesting legal matter

THERE  is an interesting matter engaging the attention of the Chief Justice involving the Commissioner of Police and the DPP. The DPP apparently instructed the police to charge the Commissioner with rape ,and the Commissioner approached the High Court for an order preventing him being prosecuted. The Chief Justice issued an order calling upon the DPP for her to show why her order should not be quashed. I find the proceedings very interesting and would like to add my piece to it.
The Chief Justice is reported to have told counsel for the DPP that he did not ask that the DPP show whether there was sufficient evidence, what the Chief Justice said he wanted was an analysis by the DPP detailing her thinking at the time she recommended the prosecution of the Commissioner.
At first blush it seems to me that an analysis of anyone’s thinking on a matter as this would necessarily involve the exercise of discretion whether the witnesses who will testify should be believed. If that is so, then it becomes a question of fact for the consideration of a jury and no one shall attempt to direct the jury what facts they should accept or reject. A jury in Common Law countries cannot be asked to give reasons for their findings on facts.
But I have a more fundamental question in mind. Does the Chief Justice have the jurisdiction to question the DPP at this stage? If the person is charged then a preliminary inquiry will be held and if no case is made out it will be thrown out. On the other hand if there is a committal, the DPP has the power and authority to enter a nolle prosequi and the person will be freed. The constitution provides for the DPP not to be subject to the direction or control of any person or authority, and this includes a Chief Justice.
The DPP is also vested with power and authority to take over any criminal prosecution and discontinue same. Can that power be challenged if she takes over a case pending in the court and order the discontinuance of same?
This action brought by Henry Greene has very serious implications touching the constitution and the powers of the DPP. I have been told that many eminent judges in matters dealing with serious issues have invited the parties to be represented by senior lawyers. Green has the advantage of senior counsel. I have no complaints with counsel now appearing for the DPP, and I note that a Solicitor General, Ms Seeta Ramlall, has recently been appointed. She is a legal practitioner of many years standing, and her appointment as Solicitor General, who is the principal adviser to the government, suggests that she is of exceptional ability. She ought to appear before His Honour along with Mr Harnanan to represent the DPP’s case

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.