I take great umbrage (and I laugh too) at the utter nonsense that Jinnah Rahman penned (in the Kaieteur News-June 03), intimating that the PNC and PPP have a lot of common evils. For starters, Rahman is ‘forcing the issue’ as his actual caption suggests. He refers to the Jagdeo ‘regime’ but in his comparison, he says the PNC ‘dictatorship.’ Maybe Rahman is confused semantically. Anyway, he uses (of all things) the ‘Sharma’ crisis as his pivot, and here again, he self-debunks. Rahman writes that the “attempt to try and close down CNS Channel 6 television, again, will confirm the charges that this country is run by a dictator – worst than Forbes Burnham.” But he cannot establish this. In fact, what he does is to confirm the very opposite of what he is trying to prove. He is like many modern art and literary critics who say a ‘piece’ of work is good or bad, but have no corroborative evidence. In other words, there is nothing but ‘fluff’ and ‘vacuity’ in their presentations. No wonder there is no proof nor logic in Rahman’s little missive.
Rahman in his attempt to portray a similarity between the two parties says that he remembers how near impossible it was for the PPP to produce the Mirror newspaper and how intense was the suffering under the Burnham dictatorship in this regard. Well Sir, is it so now? Is this what obtains today with the Stabroek and Kaieteur News? So Jagdeo does not need a ‘history lesson.’ You need to be honest.
In your meanderings you state that “(Guyana is) either a democracy – that upholds (the) constitution and the rule of law or (… is) de facto one party state. You also say that “(Guyana) cannot be both.” And again I ask, is this not obtaining in Guyana? After all, you are lamenting the evils of the PNC such as a lack of democracy and a series of rigged elections. But how come you missed that with the advent of the PPP to political office in 1992 there has been a restoration of democracy and now there are free and fair elections? So you are right: “(There is) not going to (be) a repeat of the PNC dictatorship. That is now history.
In closing, let me once again say that you are further embarrassing yourself. For indeed if one is to go to the archives (or any place that documented the PNC’s history) and for the “purposes of educating (the) young readers, the Burnham regime used the courts to place heavy fines on the Mirror and the Catholic Standard publications…” but nothing of the sort is happening to the Stabroek and the Kaieteur. Now if and when one goes to the “…Public Free Library and finds the records and makes comparisons between this Jagdeo regime and the Burnham dictatorship,” that person will see the activities of the ‘House of Israel,’ the slaying of Walter Rodney etc. and ad infinitum. If this is okay, you can take that person along and do the comparison.








