NDIA takes issue with lies in Kaieteur News

RECENT criticisms by the Kaieteur News in articles titled “$5.2M sluice door estimate questionable” dated February 28, 2011 and “$5.2M sluice door…Wood materials cost $400,000” dated March 1, 2011 are attempts by this newspaper to misrepresent and obfuscate facts. The Ministry of Agriculture’s National Drainage and Irrigation Authority (NDIA) takes issue with these invectives since they display poor journalism. In KN article dated February 28, 2011, a number of unmitigated lies were evident which evokes a response from the MOA’s NDIA to highlighting the verifiable truth.
In KN article dated March 1, 2011 the paper attempted a cover up which exposes their poor journalism even further.
Here are the misrepresentations juxtaposed against the facts:
1.                   MISREPRESENTATION: The articles both mentioned one sluice door.
FACT: Two sluice doors are to be replaced, which is evident in the bill of quantity and it is evident that bidders understand because their bids were for two doors.
2.                   MISREPRESENTATION: The Kaieteur News mentioned the estimated cost of one       sluice door at $5.2M.
FACT: The actual cost of replacement of one door is $1.25M without the cost for associated civil works.
3.                   MISREPRESENTATION: The Kaieteur News omitted other components included in the estimated cost.
FACT: The other components included in the estimated cost are  the installation of stop logs,  de-watering the pits of both sluice gates,  removal of existing sluice doors, install new doors, service and repair the lifting mechanism, other associated works including wire ropes, pulleys, gate guides, guiding strips and the installation of various new components; a contingency sum for unforeseen works, cost for performance bond, cost for insurances as contained in the National Procurement and Tender Administration Board (NPTAB) standard bidding document. These are cost elements that the Kaieteur News maliciously omitted in its story.
4.                   MISREPRESENTATION: The article inferred that remedial works had been undertaken by the NDIA.
FACT: The NDIA has not undertaken remedial works on the structure over the last few years. Farmers have now made representation to the Ministry of Agriculture and the NDIA is identifying persons to undertake works.
5.                   MISREPRESENTATION: The KN article of March 1, 2011 highlighting wire ropes, pulleys, gate guides and guiding strips in a picture.

FACT: Some of these components have deteriorated over time and this will not be evident in a picture. The newspaper has not drawn attention to the deteriorated components but rather wants to paint a picture that these components are in perfect condition.

Other examples of misrepresentation of facts in earlier articles are:
(1)   “Technically sound, feasible Hope Canal project delayed until mid-January” (December 21, 2010)
MISREPRESENTATION: The newspaper contended that works on the canal was delayed until mid-January.
FACTS: This was dishonest as the Minister of Agriculture’s comments were grossly misrepresented by the Kaieteur News since Minister Persaud said that “work at the Hope canal is stalled” but “there are other works which will continue”.
(2)    “Laptop Plunder” (February 11, 2011)
MISREPRESENTATION: In this article the Kaieteur News claims that the government has undertaken the Hope Project “against the advice of every engineer.”
FACTS: Studies by both local and international experts have all agreed that such an outlet is necessary to alleviate the adverse effects of climate change, particularly on the East Coast of Demerara, Mahaica and Mahaicony areas. Hydraulic modelling of the EDWC was carried out in 2004 under the Hydrology and Water Resources study for the Guyana D&I rehabilitation project, and was further updated in 2005 by the Task Force for Infrastructure Recovery (TFIR), which provided analytical output from which recommendations were derived in improving the flow and discharge system. The Final Report of the Task Force for Infrastructure Recovery (TFIR), prepared by experts from Mott MacDonald and local engineers, with inputs from engineers out of Holland, recommended such an outlet. Also, assessment in the Guyana Floods Geotechnical and Hydraulic Assessment of the EDWC, UNDAC, in February 2005 suggested the same.
(3)   Agri Ministry says Ruby Backdam bridge was built a decade ago (Kaieteur News articles, August 24-25, 2009)
MISREPRESENTATION: The newspaper stated in its articles that the bridge was recently built by the Ministry of Agriculture.
FACT: The Ministry of Agriculture’s Agricultural Support Services Project has not constructed any bridge at Ruby Back as published on the front page of the August 24, 2009 edition of the Kaieteur News. In fact, the bridge was built more than a decade ago under the IFAD funded East Bank Essequibo Development Project.
(4)   “Prominent engineer questions transparency of Hope Canal Project – NDIA claims considered hollow” (January 10, 2011)
MISREPRESENTATION: Excavation works for the Hope Canal was claimed by the Kaieteur News to be a basic hourly rate of $12,000 per hour.
FACT: This $12,000 per hour rate being claimed by the Kaieteur News is totally untrue as a contract was awarded for $24,700 per day by the National Procurement and Tender Administration on October 27th, 2010 which was significantly cheaper. It was indeed surprising that the Kaieteur News had chosen to write such an article since the newspaper had published all the bids on Thursday, September 16, 2010 and their corresponding tendered sums along with the engineers estimate.
The MOA’s National Drainage and Irrigation Authority (NDIA) views the recent efforts by the newspaper to discredit necessary investments of the government toward development and rehabilitation works as an orchestrated attempt to create mischief and mislead the public.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE :
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
All our printed editions are available online
emblem3
Subscribe to the Guyana Chronicle.
Sign up to receive news and updates.
We respect your privacy.