JUSTICE Brassington Reynolds, the presiding judge in the Essequibo double murder case, was yesterday critical of a report in the Stabroek News that related to the publication of what took place at a voir dire (a trial within a trial).
![]() Murder accused Joanna Denhai being escorted from court yesterday. |
|
In this country, it is illegal for the press to publish evidence at a voir dire, since what is revealed in the absence of the jury is not intended for the jury’s ears … and only becomes jury material dependent on the judge’s ruling.
At the present trial, the accused, house-wife Joanna Denhai, 36, is indicted for the murder of her two children, Jamal 7, and Keisha, 9, between January 30 and August 31, 2005.
The mixed jury was sent out of sight and hearing to make provision for the holding of a voir dire by the trial judge in order to determine the admissibility of a caution statement taken from the accused.
The voir dire was sparked off by defence counsel James Bond who had objected to leading Prosecuting counsel Miss Zamilla Alli tendering in evidence an alleged caution statement, which counsel is alleging was not obtained in accordance with the judge’s rules.
The judge had taken on the job to determine the admissibility of the caution statement by the holding of a voir dire.
On the resumption yesterday, after the jury left the Court for the jury room to provide for the continuation of the voir dire, the judge held the Stabroek News newspaper aloft and pointed out that apparently, due to the ignorance of a young reporter, problems had been created that could cause implications for all those involved, including the prosecution, the defence counsel, and the accused.
Justice Brassington Reynolds consulted the lawyers involved with a view to finding out what effect the offending article would have on them.
Defence lawyer Bond was concerned with the speedy trial of his client and promised to make his views known later.
However, years ago, a similar thing had happened and a prosecutor had urged the trial judge to stop the trial in the interest of justice. But, the judge, refusing, said, “I will warn the jury. What we have is a trial by jury — not trial by newspapers.”
On the other hand the voir dire is continuing.
So far, three witnesses have testified at the voir dire. They include Cpl Phillip Walters and Police Officer Hugh Jessamy, and for the defence, accused Joanna Denhai, who testified under oath.
Representing the prosecution are Miss Zamilla Alli, Miss Latchmie Rahamat and Ms Rhondel Weever.
Lawyer James Bond, in association with Miss Joann Bond, is appearing for the accused.








